Connect with us

Latest

Super tax is constitutionally valid, rules Federal Constitutional Court

FEDERAL CONSTITUTION COURT

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) of Pakistan upheld the constitutionality of the super tax introduced under Sections 4B and 4C of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, backing the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR).

However, it excluded capital gains from the disposal of immovable property or securities held for a prescribed period, The News reported on Thursday.

The FCC passed its judgement in a case filed by DG Khan Cement Company Limited and others. This judgement vindicates the position pursued by the Federation of Pakistan and the FBR.

The FCC ruled that the super tax is an additional tax on income, drawing its legislative sanction from entry 47, Part 1 of the Federal Legislative List of the Constitution.

“The necessary corollary to the above is that if a certain class of income is exempt from tax under the law regulating it i.e. the ordinance,” the judgement read and added, “For instance, where no tax is payable on capital gains arising on disposal of immoveable property or securities either for being held beyond a certain period or is inherited or is otherwise exempted from the ordinance, no super tax shall be payable on such capital gains on disposal of immoveable property or securities”.

The FCC ruled that the same principle “shall apply” to any capital gains on disposal of agricultural property, which even otherwise cannot be subject to income arising therefrom either by usage or by disposal.

Top official sources in the FBR said that the tax machinery so far collected Rs290 billion on account of Super Tax in the first nine months of the current fiscal year, and it might go up to Rs315 billion by the end of June 2026.

In the extensive and detailed, almost 300-page judgement, the court critically examined several complex taxation issues.

The court held that the super tax levied under Section 4B (introduced by the Finance Act, 2015 for the rehabilitation of temporarily displaced persons from tax years 2015-2022)) and Section 4C (introduced by the Finance Act, 2022 imposed on ‘High Earning Persons’ from tax year 2022 and onwards) is a valid exercise of parliament’s taxing power under Entry 47 of the Federal Legislative List of the Constitution of Pakistan, being a tax on income.

In the case of section 4B, the court rejected the argument that the levy was a fee and not a tax, holding that the mere mention of a purpose did not automatically render the tax a fee in the absence of any direct service linkage to any beneficiary.

The court placed Section 4B squarely within the domain of taxation, validly passed through the Finance Act, thereby upholding all the high courts’ judgements to this effect.

In respect of Section 4C Super Tax, the court further held that the provision is a self-contained provision with its own charge, assessment, and payment mechanism; there is no constitutional bar on so-called “double taxation”.

Significantly, the court reaffirmed the doctrine of judicial restraint in fiscal matters, holding that the wisdom and policy of taxation lie with the legislature, and that judicial review is confined to questions of legislative competence, constitutional compliance, and absence of arbitrariness.

In another significant finding on the jurisdictional side, the court found the FBR and the Commissioner Inland Revenue (if properly authorised) to enjoy the powers of instituting and defending proceedings relating to tax matters arising from constitutional challenges.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest

CDA Prepares Major Operation Against Bari Imam House Despite Political Influence; Strict Action Planned in Case of Resistance

Bari_Imam

ISLAMABAD: The Capital Development Authority (CDA) has completed preparations for a possible major operation against Bari Imam House in Islamabad to reclaim approximately 200 kanals of disputed government land. Heavy machinery, police deployment and security arrangements have been put in place, while authorities have reportedly decided to take strict legal action in case of any resistance during the operation.

According to well-placed CDA sources, Chairman CDA and Chief Commissioner Islamabad has held several high-level meetings with the Deputy Commissioner, district administration and senior police officials, including the Inspector General of Islamabad Police, to review the proposed operation.

The CDA chairman has also held multiple meetings with relevant authority officials and operational teams, seeking detailed briefings on machinery, manpower, security arrangements, emergency response and the overall strategy required to ensure the operation is carried out effectively. The authority’s Legal Department has also been consulted to examine the legal implications and ensure compliance with court directions.

CDA officials maintain that the Bari Imam House administration does not possess any authenticated government document establishing ownership of the disputed land. They maintain that official records of government property are held by the CDA and district administration.

Political Connections Under Scrutiny

Bari Imam House has remained under the administration of Raja Sarfraz Akram for several years. Various political and social events have been held at the premises, with Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar and Federal Minister for Railways Hanif Abbasi among the prominent political figures reported to have attended events there.

Their participation has prompted questions about possible political patronage and influence surrounding the disputed property. However, attendance at these events alone does not establish involvement in the land dispute, and the concerned political figures’ responses are awaited.

Court Directives Put Ownership Claims to the Test

The Islamabad High Court has directed the applicant to submit documentary evidence of ownership within five days and instructed the CDA to examine the documents and issue a reasoned decision within two days after receiving them. In the absence of satisfactory ownership documents, the authority may proceed in accordance with the law.

CDA sources say preparations also include contingency arrangements to deal with any obstruction or resistance. Strict legal action has reportedly been planned if anyone attempts to obstruct the operation.

The proposed operation could take place towards the end of this week or during the following week, subject to the completion of legal requirements and final approval by the relevant authorities.

With machinery and operational teams reportedly ready, attention is now focused on the CDA’s next move and whether the long-running dispute over approximately 200 kanals of land will finally reach a decisive stage.

Continue Reading

Latest

Houthi Militias Launch Missile Attack on Saudi Arabia’s Southern Region

houthi-missile

The Saudi-led coalition forces have intercepted and destroyed a missile fired by Houthi militias, according to the coalition.

Saudi authorities reported that no casualties or damage to property had been reported in the missile attack.

It is worth mentioning that a cruise missile launched by Houthi militias from Yemen towards the Saudi capital, Riyadh, was also intercepted and destroyed a day earlier.

Continue Reading

Latest

Cyberattacks on Global Companies, Millions of Dollars in Cryptocurrency Stolen; 24-Year-Old Hacker Jailed

bitcoin

A 24-year-old British hacker has been sentenced to six years in prison in the United States for breaching company systems through fake mobile messages and stealing cryptocurrency worth more than $11.6 million.

According to the BBC, Tyler Buchanan, 24, is from Dundee, Scotland. He had been involved in hacking activities since his teenage years and was part of the cybercrime group known as “Scattered Spider.”

Between 2021 and 2023, Buchanan and his associates sent hundreds of fraudulent messages to employees of major technology and telecommunications companies.

The messages warned employees that their work accounts were about to expire and instructed them to log in again immediately through a provided link.

These links redirected employees to fake websites designed to look like genuine company websites, where they entered their usernames, passwords and other confidential information.

The young hacker also developed an automated system on Telegram to collect the stolen information.

Later, the group used the stolen credentials and SIM-swapping techniques to gain access to cryptocurrency accounts belonging to US citizens.

One victim alone lost $1.67 million in December 2022. Buchanan admitted his involvement in the crimes.

Following his guilty plea, the hacker was extradited from Spain to the United States, where a court sentenced him to 72 months in prison on November 17.

Continue Reading

Read More

Bari_Imam Bari_Imam
Latest2 hours ago

CDA Prepares Major Operation Against Bari Imam House Despite Political Influence; Strict Action Planned in Case of Resistance

ISLAMABAD: The Capital Development Authority (CDA) has completed preparations for a possible major operation against Bari Imam House in Islamabad...

houthi-missile houthi-missile
Latest2 hours ago

Houthi Militias Launch Missile Attack on Saudi Arabia’s Southern Region

The Saudi-led coalition forces have intercepted and destroyed a missile fired by Houthi militias, according to the coalition. Saudi authorities...

bitcoin bitcoin
Latest14 hours ago

Cyberattacks on Global Companies, Millions of Dollars in Cryptocurrency Stolen; 24-Year-Old Hacker Jailed

A 24-year-old British hacker has been sentenced to six years in prison in the United States for breaching company systems...

human human
Latest14 hours ago

Importance of the Word ‘Human’ Grows in the Age of Artificial Intelligence; ‘Human’ Named Word of the Year 2026

According to the BBC, Cambridge Dictionary announced that the debate over what it truly means to be human in the...

PETROL PETROL
Latest15 hours ago

Government Announces Further Reduction in Petroleum Prices

ISLAMABAD: The Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (OGRA), in a notification, announced revised petroleum prices under the pricing mechanism approved...

bilawal-bhutto-zardari bilawal-bhutto-zardari
Latest15 hours ago

Referendum Is Unconstitutional; Coercion and Creating a Favourable Environment Will Not Work, Says Bilawal Bhutto Zardari

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has said that a referendum on creating new provinces is unconstitutional...

Mustafa Kamal Mustafa Kamal
Latest23 hours ago

Mustafa Kamal Warns Bilawal, Says He Will Be Responsible for Any Bloodshed in Sindh

KARACHI: Federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal has termed the creation of smaller provinces inevitable, saying Pakistan cannot function effectively without...

rabia-ahsan rabia-ahsan
Latest23 hours ago

Anchor Rabia Ahsan Murder Case: Husband Sent to Adiala Jail on Judicial Remand

RAWALPINDI: Ahsan Tahir, the husband arrested in connection with anchor Rabia Ahsan’s mysterious murder, was produced before a court after...

Gold Prices Gold Prices
Latest23 hours ago

Gold Prices in Pakistan Drop Sharply, Fall Below Rs400,000 per Tola

KARACHI: Gold prices in Pakistan recorded a significant decline. According to the All Pakistan Gems and Jewellers Association, the price...

Bushra Bibi Bushra Bibi
Latest24 hours ago

IHC Orders Provision of All Possible Medical Facilities to Bushra Bibi in Jail

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has directed jail authorities to provide all possible medical and other necessary facilities to...

Trending