Connect with us

Latest

9/11 transformed global order, weakened international legal framework: Mushahid Hussain

Mushahid Hussain

Islamabad: The September 11, 2001, attacks marked a fundamental turning point in global politics, transforming the international security environment and triggering a prolonged “War on Terror” whose consequences extended far beyond the immediate aftermath. The ensuing wars imposed massive human and economic costs, weakened the international legal order, destabilized Pakistan and regional countries, and triggered the collapse of the unipolar US hegemonic order. In this period of global transition, Pakistan has emerged as a resilient country, with the potential to confront current challenges and chart a way forward.

This was discussed at a guest talk titled “9/11 at 25: The Day that Changed the World”, organized by the Institute of Policy Studies (IPS), Islamabad, in collaboration with the Department of International Relations, Bahria University, Islamabad. The talk featured Senator Mushahid Hussain Sayed, chairman of the Pakistan-China Institute; Khalid Rahman, chairman IPS, and Dr Saira Nawaz Abbasi, head of the International Relations Department at Bahria University.

Delivering the keynote address, Mushahid Hussain Sayed argued that 9/11 fundamentally altered the global balance of power and accelerated the decline of unipolar American dominance. Questioning whether the US response to the attacks was proportionate, he contended that the event was subsequently used to pursue a broader geopolitical agenda. Referring to developments preceding 9/11, including the Project for the New American Century and its advocacy for reshaping the Middle East, he highlighted the extent to which regime change and military intervention had become embedded in US strategic thinking.

Citing figures from the Brown University’s ‘Costs of War’ study, Mushahid Hussain noted the enormous human and financial costs of the wars that followed 9/11, including approximately $8 trillion in US expenditure, around one million direct deaths, millions of indirect deaths, and tens of millions of displaced people. He observed that the US intervention in Afghanistan alone consumed approximately $2 trillion over two decades. He further argued that the failure to achieve the intended strategic objectives exposed the limitations of military intervention and contributed to the weakening of American global influence.

Discussing Afghanistan and Pakistan, Mushahid Hussain identified the post-9/11 period as particularly consequential for the region. He argued that political arrangements imposed in Afghanistan failed to adequately account for the country’s historical and social realities, while Pakistan suffered severe destabilization, particularly in the former FATA region. He also pointed to constant expansion of Indian influence in Afghanistan during the US occupation as a major consequence of the post-9/11 environment.

Turning to the broader global implications, he contrasted US war spending with China’s emphasis on economic connectivity and infrastructure during the same period, arguing that this divergence contributed to China’s rise. He also highlighted Russia’s subsequent recovery under President Vladimir Putin and the emergence of Muslim-majority middle powers, including Pakistan, as part of an increasingly significant pattern in the evolving international system.

Mushahid Hussain further identified the rise of Islamophobia and anti-Muslim prejudice as one of the most enduring consequences of the post-9/11 period. He noted the growth of right-wing political movements in parts of the West and linked contemporary tensions to longer historical narratives surrounding Islam and the West. He stressed the need to understand these competing historical and geopolitical visions while clearly distinguishing facts from propaganda.

In his remarks, Khalid Rahman emphasized that the declaration of a “War on Terror” represented a significant departure from treating terrorism primarily as a criminal matter, requiring investigation and prosecution. He identified the erosion of the international legal order as one of the most serious consequences of the post-9/11 response. He also underscored the continuing importance of the UN and international law.

Dr. Saira Nawaz noted that studying 9/11 is important for understanding how systemic change is shaped. She noted that through speech act states securitize a particular issue to serve their domestic and international interests; President Bush also used this mechanism to equate the 9/11 incident with an American security issue. Thus, security is not an objective phenomenon, but rather a subjective matter for every state actor.

The event provided an opportunity to critically examine the long-term geopolitical, legal, economic, and societal consequences of 9/11 and the subsequent “War on Terror,” while reflecting on the transformation of the international order over the past quarter century.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest

IHC Orders Provision of All Possible Medical Facilities to Bushra Bibi in Jail

Bushra Bibi

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has directed jail authorities to provide all possible medical and other necessary facilities to Bushra Bibi during the hearing of appeals challenging the convictions of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) founder Imran Khan and his wife in the £190 million case.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar and Justice Muhammad Asif also heard a petition seeking the production of Bushra Bibi’s medical reports before the court.

During the proceedings, her counsel, Sardar Latif Khosa, informed the court that a fresh application had also been filed on her behalf, expressing concerns that she could lose her eyesight under the prevailing circumstances.

Latif Khosa said Bushra Bibi faced a risk of infection following her surgery while in jail, which could potentially affect her eyesight.

He also read out an affidavit submitted to the court, stating that sanitary conditions in Bushra Bibi’s prison cell were extremely poor.

According to the affidavit, seven small snakes had been found in her cell. It further alleged that a jail official, identified as Sabtain, killed the snakes and subsequently had the area covered with cement.

The court directed the authorities to ensure that Bushra Bibi received all possible medical facilities in jail. It further ordered that a specialist doctor be made available if required and that complaints regarding cleanliness and hygiene in her cell be addressed.

The court observed that the concerns raised by her counsel should be taken into consideration and appropriate measures should be taken accordingly.

Meanwhile, the Islamabad Advocate General informed the court that Bushra Bibi was being provided medical facilities in accordance with jail rules and that she had previously been taken outside the prison for medical treatment whenever necessary.

Continue Reading

Latest

PPP’s Mindset Condemnable; Bilawal’s Remarks About Bloodshed in Karachi Must Be Addressed, Says Hafiz Naeem

hafiznaeemurrehman

ISLAMABAD: Jamaat-e-Islami Emir Hafiz Naeemur Rehman has strongly criticised the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), saying its mindset is condemnable and that Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s remarks about bloodshed in Karachi must be addressed.

Speaking at a press conference in Islamabad, Hafiz Naeem said the PPP had also triggered ethnic riots in 1972 by introducing a language bill. He said any conduct that could lead to violence and bloodshed must be addressed, adding that the party should be questioned over how it could issue such threats.

He said the politics of the PPP and Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) would no longer be accepted in Larkana or Karachi. He added that Jamaat-e-Islami supported increasing the number of administrative provinces, provided a constitutional framework for creating new provinces was presented.

Hafiz Naeem said Bilawal Bhutto Zardari had specifically mentioned Karachi and Mirpurkhas, thereby identifying urban areas of Sindh in his remarks.

He alleged that the PPP had consistently relied on creating or exploiting fears of Sindhi-Muhajir clashes to maintain its hold on power. He said if the party had objections to the existing system, it should resign from all government positions, including the presidency.

The Jamaat-e-Islami chief said Sindh had once been a peaceful province where people lived together like brothers, but the PPP had laid the foundations for ethnic violence in the province.

He alleged that whenever questions were raised about the party’s corruption or alleged embezzlement, it attempted to create divisions and provoke confrontation among people.

Hafiz Naeem further accused the PPP of repeatedly undermining democracy. Questioning its criticism of the government, he asked how Asif Ali Zardari had become president if the party believed the government was illegitimate. He said the PPP was among the beneficiaries of the 2024 general elections and alleged that irregularities had also occurred during the Karachi mayoral election.

He claimed that the people of Karachi disliked the PPP and alleged that the party had illegitimately secured seven National Assembly seats from the city. He challenged Bilawal Bhutto Zardari to produce Form 45 documents for those constituencies.

Hafiz Naeem reiterated that the PPP was still part of the ruling coalition and questioned why Zardari did not resign from the presidency if the government was illegitimate.

Referring to the possibility of governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, he said that if such a move was imposed unlawfully, it was Zardari’s signature that would authorise it. He also questioned the PPP’s position on Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), asking why it had helped remove the PTI government if Bilawal was now expressing sympathy for the party.

Separately, the Jamaat-e-Islami chief expressed concern over the delay in the start of sugarcane crushing, saying farmers were facing difficulties. He demanded that the sugarcane price be fixed at Rs700 per maund.

He said the agriculture sector was declining and announced that Jamaat-e-Islami would stage sit-ins outside sugar mills on Friday.

Continue Reading

Latest

Pakistani Astronaut to Join China’s Shenzhou-24 Space Mission, Set to Make History

Shenzhou-24 Space Mission

ISLAMABAD: A Pakistani astronaut will serve as a payload specialist aboard China’s Shenzhou-24 crewed space mission, marking a historic milestone in Pakistan-China space cooperation.

According to Chinese state media outlet CGTN, this will be the first time a foreign astronaut participates in China’s human spaceflight programme.

Preparations for the Shenzhou-24 mission are currently underway, and it is expected to be launched soon. According to the Chinese space authorities, the Pakistani astronaut will stay aboard the space station for a short period.

The participation of a Pakistani astronaut in the mission is being viewed as a significant development in space cooperation between Pakistan and China. It will mark the first joint spaceflight involving Chinese and foreign astronauts under China’s crewed space programme.

The mission is also being seen as the beginning of a new era of international cooperation in space exploration.

Continue Reading

Read More

Bushra Bibi Bushra Bibi
Latest14 minutes ago

IHC Orders Provision of All Possible Medical Facilities to Bushra Bibi in Jail

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has directed jail authorities to provide all possible medical and other necessary facilities to...

hafiznaeemurrehman hafiznaeemurrehman
Latest23 minutes ago

PPP’s Mindset Condemnable; Bilawal’s Remarks About Bloodshed in Karachi Must Be Addressed, Says Hafiz Naeem

ISLAMABAD: Jamaat-e-Islami Emir Hafiz Naeemur Rehman has strongly criticised the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), saying its mindset is condemnable and...

Shenzhou-24 Space Mission Shenzhou-24 Space Mission
Latest30 minutes ago

Pakistani Astronaut to Join China’s Shenzhou-24 Space Mission, Set to Make History

ISLAMABAD: A Pakistani astronaut will serve as a payload specialist aboard China’s Shenzhou-24 crewed space mission, marking a historic milestone...

malik ahmed khan malik ahmed khan
Latest32 minutes ago

Why Does PPP Talk of Bloodshed Over Sindh’s Division After Passing Resolutions for Punjab’s Division? Asks Malik Ahmad

LAHORE: Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Ahmad Khan has questioned why the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), which supported resolutions for the...

mir raza father mir hussain mir raza father mir hussain
Latest49 minutes ago

Mir Raza Case: Something Will Emerge Very Soon, Says Mir Hussain

KARACHI: Joint Investigation Team (JIT) head DIG Irfan Baloch met Mir Raza’s father, Mir Hussain, in Karachi as part of...

crude oil crude oil
Latest1 hour ago

US Oil and Fuel Inventories Surge, Crude Oil Prices Fall in Global Markets

NEW YORK: Global oil prices declined after reports of a significant increase in US crude oil and fuel inventories. However,...

Pindi test Pindi test
Latest1 hour ago

Rawalpindi Test: Kumara Takes Four Wickets as Pakistan’s Lead Surpasses 100 Runs

RAWALPINDI: Pakistan extended their lead to 123 runs by the lunch break on the second day of the Rawalpindi Test...

peshawar police peshawar police
Latest1 hour ago

Attack on Police Peace Committee President’s Vehicle in Lakki Marwat; 4 Personnel Injured

PESHAWAR: A vehicle belonging to the president of the Police Peace Committee in Begukhel, Lakki Marwat, came under attack, leaving...

AMANAT ALI AMANAT ALI
Latest2 hours ago

From a Year in Bed to the Spotlight: Shafqat Amanat Ali Reveals His Battle with a Rare Blood Cancer

ISLAMABAD: Renowned Pakistani singer Shafqat Amanat Ali has revealed that he battled Multiple Myeloma, a serious form of blood cancer,...

Mustafa Kamal Mustafa Kamal
Latest15 hours ago

NPC-Free-Medical-CampFederal Health Minister to inaugurate free screening camp at NPC tomorrow

ISLAMABAD:Federal Minister for Health Syed Mustafa Kamal will inaugurate a free screening camp at the National Press Club (NPC) Islamabad...

Trending